Glock 17 vs. 19: Which Model is the Best?

Alright, it’s the fierce debate we all need a little more of in our lives: Glock 19 or 17? Cmon, you know it’s weighing on your conscience. We’ll help kickstart things. To start, the two represent some of Glock’s most iconic pistols, dating back to the 1980s. Why do so many gun owners flock toward these models? Well, it’s pretty simple. Whether you choose the Glock 19 or 17 model, you’re getting one of the most reliable 9mm firearms on the market. So, how did the two originate? What differentiates the Glock 19 vs. 17? And which is right for you? We’ll answer all that and more in this edition of Shooting the Sh!t.

Glock 19 vs. 17: An Overview of Each Firearm

Before we dive into performance and best uses for each model, let’s first take a brief look at where they’ve come from. We’ll start with the Glock 17. Often referred to as the G17, this firearm hit the American market in 1982. Fun fact, it was named after its 17-round magazine capacity, which at the time was a pretty big deal, to say the least. It also represented Gaston Glock’s 17th patent, initially developed for the Austrian military.

Glock’s primary aim with the G17—and later G17 L—was to create a reliable, high-capacity 9mm handgun for military and law enforcement. The utilization of a polymer frame was groundbreaking at the time, offering durability while reducing weight. With fewer parts than traditional handguns, the G17 became synonymous with simplicity and reliability, which we can all agree goes along with the brand’s dedication to speed, safety, and efficiency.

Glock 19

When analyzing the Glock 19 vs. the Glock 17, you’ll notice a few differences. It was introduced in 1988, offering a more compact version of the G17. Its design was driven by the growing need for a more concealable firearm without significantly sacrificing the firepower and reliability Glock had become known for.

While it was still crafted with the Austrian military and law enforcement in mind, the G19 was also released to appeal to civilians who were looking to get into concealed carry. The firearm itself maintained much of the G17’s DNA, however, the slightly reduced size helped Glock expand into new customer markets. The balance between size, weight, and capacity was carefully considered, today making the G19 one of the most sought-after compact pistols you can find.

Glock 17 vs. 19: Features and Aftermarket Customizations

Continuing the Glock 19 vs. 17 debate, let’s look at the features and customizations you can apply to each model. The Glock 17 features a length of 7.32 inches, a width of 1.18 inches, and a total weight of 31.91 ounces when fully loaded. The slightly smaller Glock 19 features a length of 6.85 inches, the same width of 1.18 inches, and a weight of 29.98 ounces when fully loaded. The two charts below give you a good idea of what to expect.

* G17, Charts Courtesy of Magill’s Glockstore

*G19

For the most part, the two models are very similar in terms of features and shooting performance. The G17’s larger size may make it more accurate if you’re shooting from a longer distance, though. The real question is, how do you make your Glock 19 and/or 17 stand out from the crowd when at the shooting range or with friends? Through aftermarket parts and accessories. And thankfully, the Glock 19 or 17 are both great options for upgrades. At Zaffiri Precision, we offer high-quality parts like custom slides, G17 and G19 barrels, and much more. Our Made in America selection of parts and accessories are designed to boost your favorite firearm’s looks, durability, and even performance. We even offer additional add-ons such as threaded barrels, red dots and sights, and compensators. To learn more about how we can take your firearm to the next level, feel free to contact the team at any time! Now, let’s get back to your regularly scheduled programming.

Glock 19 vs. 17: Which is Right for Me?

This is what it all comes down to after all. If you’re considering the Glock 19 vs. 17, you’re probably asking yourself this. Well, the answer is fairly simple (or complicated, depending on how you look at it.) Let’s say you’re on the hunt for a new firearm to use at the shooting range. You want something that is both powerful and accurate from medium to long-range distances. Well, between the Glock 19 vs. 17, the 17 would most likely be your best choice. Those looking for the right firearm for home defense and target shooting tend to choose the G17 over the G19 because of its larger size and 17-round magazine capacity.

Now, perhaps you’re a first-time gun owner or a woman looking to find the perfect concealed-carry pistol. In the battle of the Glock 19 vs. 17, the G19 may be the right choice for you. Despite its smaller size than the G17, the 19 still offers a pretty substantial magazine capacity. Standard Glock 19 magazines hold 15 rounds of 9mm ammunition, providing a nice balance between size and firepower.

Ultimately, the choice is up to you. It’s important to consult with an expert before making your final decision. If you enjoyed this piece, be sure to check out the rest of our Shooting the Sh!t blogs, including our ultimate gift guide for gun lovers (cough, cough, the holidays are fast approaching.)

FAQs

What is better? A Glock 19 or 17?

The answer depends on what you’re looking for. If you’re looking for concealed carry, you’ll probably want the Glock 19 vs. 17.

Why do Navy SEALs choose the Glock 19, not the Glock 17?

The Navy SEALs chose the Glock 19 because it saves them valuable weight compared to the Glock 17 and Sig P226 models.

Does the FBI use the Glock 17 or 19?

The FBI relies on both the Gen 5 Glock 17 and 19 models.